R&D Tax Credit for Custom Manufacturers: How the Shrinking-Back Rule Finds the Part of a Job That Qualifies
The R&D tax credit for custom manufacturers is not all-or-nothing. When a full machine or assembly does not qualify, the shrinking-back rule looks for the subassembly, part, or production process that does.

TL;DR
- The R&D tax credit for custom manufacturers is tested one business component at a time. A whole job that does not qualify may still contain a part, subassembly, or process that does.
- The shrinking-back rule in Treasury Regulation 1.41-4(b)(2) steps down from the full product to smaller subsets of elements until it finds one that meets the tests or runs out of elements.
- Production processes are their own business components, so new tooling, fixturing, or forming methods can be evaluated separately from the part they make.
Custom manufacturers often judge the R&D tax credit at the wrong level. An owner looks at a finished machine, a skid, or a custom enclosure and sees that most of it is standard work. The conclusion is that the job does not count. The tax rules do not stop there. They ask a narrower question: within that job, is there a piece of the product, or a piece of how it was made, where your team had to work through real technical uncertainty? A specific rule in the regulations, called the shrinking-back rule, is built to answer exactly that.
What the R&D tax credit is, and why custom manufacturers can qualify
The federal research credit under Internal Revenue Code Section 41 rewards businesses for qualified research expenses. These are mostly wages for people who do, directly supervise, or directly support qualifying work. They also include supplies consumed in that work and a portion of certain contract research. Custom manufacturers are frequent candidates because one-off or low-volume work often means designing something that has not been built that way before, and figuring out how to make it.
Qualification is not decided job by job or company by company. Section 41(d)(2) says the tests apply separately to each “business component.” The statute defines that as a product, process, computer software, technique, formula, or invention that you sell, lease, or license, or use in your own business. That definition is what makes the shrinking-back rule possible.
How the shrinking-back rule works under Treasury Regulation 1.41-4
Treasury Regulation 1.41-4(b)(2) lays out the order of operations:
- Start with the whole business component. The research tests are applied first to the discrete product or process, such as the complete machine you delivered.
- If the whole does not pass, step down. The tests are then applied to the most significant subset of elements of that product, then to the next most significant subset, and so on.
- Stop when something qualifies, or when nothing is left. The process continues until a subset meets the requirements or the most basic element is reached. If even that fails, the work does not qualify.
The regulation includes its own example. A motorcycle engine builder develops a new carburetor and modifies the engine design. If the engine as a whole does not meet the tests, the rule moves to the carburetor, and the work on the carburetor may be qualified research.
Two points matter for owners. First, the rule only comes into play when the full component does not qualify on its own. Second, the regulation states plainly that shrinking back is not itself a reason to exclude research activities. It is a way to find eligible work, not a way to disqualify it.
What shrinking back looks like on a custom manufacturing job
Consider a hypothetical shop that builds a custom material-handling cell for a customer. Most of the frame is standard structural steel, the conveyors are catalog items, and the controls follow the shop’s usual architecture. Taken as a whole, the cell may not meet the tests, because most of it was assembled using known methods.
Now step down a level. Suppose the customer’s parts were an unusual shape and weight, and no standard gripper or nest could hold them reliably at the required speed. The engineering team modeled several end-of-arm designs and machined two prototypes. One deflected under load, so they changed the geometry and material before landing on a design that worked. That gripper subassembly may meet the four-part test on its own:
- a permitted purpose (a new or improved function)
- reliance on engineering principles
- real uncertainty about the right design at the outset
- a process of evaluating alternatives
Under the shrinking-back rule, the time and consumed materials tied to that gripper development can often be evaluated as qualified research even though the cell as a whole was not. This example is illustrative only. The outcome on any real job depends on the specific activities, documentation, and facts.
The production process is its own business component
Custom shops often do some of their most technical work on how a part is made rather than on the part itself. Section 41(d)(2)(C) treats any plant process, machinery, or technique for commercial production of a business component as a separate business component, not as part of the item being produced.
Treasury Regulation 1.41-4(b)(1) adds that when a project develops both a product and the process to make it, each must meet the tests on its own. That cuts both ways:
- A routine part can come from a new process. Say the bracket is ordinary, but your team had to develop a new forming sequence, fixture, or welding approach to hold tolerance at volume. The process work may be evaluated separately.
- A new part can come from a routine process. If the part design was genuinely uncertain but it was made on standard equipment with standard methods, the qualifying work likely sits with the design, not the production setup.
Timing matters too. Activities after the beginning of commercial production are not qualified research. Under 1.41-4(c)(2)(iii), though, that cutoff is applied separately to the product and to its production process. Work refining a manufacturing process can still qualify after the product itself is ready. The process work has to meet the tests on its own and happen before the process is ready for commercial use.
What the shrinking-back rule does not change for the manufacturing tax credit
The rule finds the right level to test. It does not lower the bar. A few limits still apply at every level:
- The four-part test still has to be met by whatever subset you land on.
- The statutory exclusions still apply. These include adapting an existing business component to a customer’s requirement and duplicating an existing component.
- Funded research rules still apply. If a customer contract shifts the financial risk and the rights to the results away from you, that work may be excluded regardless of level.
- Depreciable equipment is not a supply. A new press or mill bought to support a process is generally not a qualified research expense. Wages and consumed trial materials tied to developing the process may be.
Records that help show where the qualifying work happened
Shrinking back works best when your files can point to the specific subassembly or process where the uncertainty lived. Helpful records often include:
- revision history on the subassembly drawings
- notes on prototypes that failed and why
- trial material and scrap tied to a specific fixture or forming method
- a reasonable link between the people involved and that piece of the job
Records created at the time of the work are typically stronger than reconstructions, though there is no single required format.
Frequently asked questions
Does the R&D tax credit for custom manufacturers require the whole product to be new?
No. The tests are applied to each business component. If the whole product does not qualify, the shrinking-back rule can look at smaller subsets of elements. A new subassembly inside an otherwise standard build may qualify.
Can the shrinking-back rule be used to disqualify work?
The regulation says shrinking back is not itself a reason to exclude research activities. It applies only when the full business component does not meet the tests.
Is a new manufacturing process evaluated separately from the part?
Yes. Section 41(d)(2)(C) treats production processes as separate business components, and each must meet the tests on its own.
Does the work have to succeed to count?
No. Treasury Regulation 1.41-4(a)(3)(ii) does not require success in developing the new or improved component. A prototype that failed can still be part of qualified research.
What does it cost to find out whether my shop’s jobs have qualifying components?
Strata offers a $0 initial assessment. A typical study is completed in roughly 4 to 8 weeks, depending on the business and how quickly information is available. Most of the work sits with Strata, not with your shop floor.
Where to start
Your team may build custom equipment, fixtures, or parts and assume the jobs are “too standard” to count. If so, the question worth asking is not whether the whole build was new. It is which piece of it, or which way of making it, your engineers had to figure out. Bring that question to us first. Request a 15-minute review and $0 initial assessment and we will help you look at your jobs at the right level.
For the IRS’s own guidance on what a research credit claim reports, including business component information, see the Instructions for Form 6765.
This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute tax or legal advice. Consult a qualified tax professional regarding your specific circumstances.
Author
Strata R&D Tax Group



